Hello everyone, it’s your host Oliver from DULAXI, and today I’m delighted to be joined by Joseph Mackey, frontman and songwriter of Melbourne-based indie/alt-folk four-piece Coconut Shy. Hailing from Australia, the band brings together elements of indie rock, folk and melodic alternative music, balancing thoughtful songwriting with arrangements that invite listeners to sing along. We’re here to discuss their latest single, “Knock”, released on 30 October 2026, and the personal story behind a song that took more than a decade to find its way into the band’s catalogue.
Before we begin our conversation with Joseph Mackey, here’s what you need to know about today’s featured project.
About Coconut Shy
Coconut Shy began as the solo indie-folk and alt-rock project of singer-songwriter Joseph Mackey before evolving into a full four-piece band in 2025. Based in Melbourne, Australia, the project has developed around Mackey’s love of songwriting, bringing together intimate lyrical themes and the expansive qualities of indie rock and folk. Drawing inspiration from artists such as Coldplay, Dire Straits, Spacey Jane and Mumford & Sons, Coconut Shy explores a musical identity that moves between reflective passages and energetic, singalong-ready choruses.
The band’s latest single, “Knock”, is a particularly personal addition to its growing catalogue. Originally written by Mackey when he was approximately 19, the song reflects the uncertainty of discovering a creative passion without knowing how to turn it into a sustainable part of everyday life. Growing up without a family precedent for pursuing the kind of creative career he envisioned, Mackey found himself questioning where he belonged in the musical world. That uncertainty eventually became the foundation for the song’s central question: “Do I knock or just walk in?” More than ten years later, the composition has taken on a different meaning, allowing Mackey to revisit the ambitions and insecurities of his younger self with greater understanding.
Having remained part of his solo performances for years, “Knock” eventually found a new direction when Mackey introduced it to his bandmates following Coconut Shy’s transition into a four-piece. The collective enthusiasm surrounding the song encouraged its development into a fuller arrangement, with the contributions of Dylan Noble on bass, Matt Meehan-Lam on drums and Timothy Chivers on electric guitar helping bring the composition into the band’s present musical identity. Recorded by Simon Paparo at Four Doors Studios, the single balances the original songwriting’s simplicity with the additional instrumental character of the full group.
Before the formation of the band, Mackey had already been developing his independent catalogue, releasing an EP in 2021 followed by the singles “Water, Water” and “The Finest Day” in 2022 and 2023 respectively. Both singles received radio airplay across Australia, marking important steps in his development as an independent musician. “Knock” follows the band’s 2026 releases “Mayfield Blush” and “Small Steps (Paces)” and will feature on Coconut Shy’s forthcoming debut album, expected in late 2026.
Having this brief introduction to today’s featured project, I’m sure both new listeners and longtime fans are interested in hearing directly from Joseph about the experiences, creative decisions and personal reflections behind “Knock”. So, without further ado, let’s begin today’s interview.

INTERVIEW SESSION
Oliver:
“Knock” was originally written when you were around 19, at a time when you knew music mattered to you but were unsure how to build a future around it. Looking back, what do you remember most clearly about that period of your life, and what was happening creatively when the song first took shape?
Joseph Mackey:
It was long ago, so my memory of specific events and things becomes hazey over time. What I do remember most clearly about that time of life, or any time of life for that matter, was how I felt rather than things I necessarily did or said. It was the first year I began to play my own original music in front of audiences, you know, surfing open mic scenes and such; I remember intuitively knowing it was something I was going to be doing for a long time. When you feel that way about a creative outlet, it’s simultaneously exhilarating and daunting. I knew I wanted to offer the creative musical ecosystem something of my own, but I wasn’t sure what in the hell that would actually look like in the tangible realities of life. That’s when I wrote this song – being that young and discovering something creative you love, you’re not really sure if “you should knock or just walk in” – to quote the song – because you’re not really sure how or even if you belong in that space.
Oliver:
The song remained in your back pocket for more than a decade before becoming a Coconut Shy release. What kept you connected to it over the years, and was there ever a point when you considered leaving it behind rather than bringing it into the band’s catalogue?
Joseph Mackey:
There was definitely a point I considered saying goodbye to it. Musically it’s a very simple song, and I hope to think my song writing ability and arsenal has improved a little since then. I also thought that it might seem somewhat out of place with music I’m currently writing, a lot of which is maybe a little more mature and multi-faceted. I think what helped me stay connected with the song is simply that is important to remember how a passion started, and “Knock” was born from the realisation of “wow, I’m about to embark on a lifelong musical journey here.” The chorus is also mad fun to play, so there’s that.
Oliver:
The central question, “Do I knock or just walk in?”, captures the uncertainty of pursuing a creative ambition without knowing whether you belong in that world. What does that question mean to you now, compared with what it meant when you first wrote it?
Joseph Mackey:
Haha, pretty easy one to answer. Nowadays that lyric means me wanting to shout a response to my younger self: “Mate, just walk in. Most people in here are questioning themselves too.”
Oliver:
You have described growing up without a family precedent for following the kind of creative path you imagined. How did that environment shape your early expectations of music, and how did you find the confidence to keep pursuing it?
Joseph Mackey:
It was a weird one. No one in my upbringing had really properly pursued something creative before; I didn’t really have a figurative textbook on it. Honestly two things helped: musical friends who shared my enthusiasm for it and, strangely, diving into the back stories of my favourite artists and bands at the time to see how they got their beginnings. That stuff was fascinating and inspiring. So many great artists in the world have come from nowhere.
Oliver:
One of the most striking lines in the song is “I’ve been nothing more than a magician baby.” What does that lyric represent in the context of your own creative identity, and why did it feel important to keep that expression at the heart of the track?
Joseph Mackey:
It came from both a literal event and a mindset of insecurity. During one of the first open mic nights I ever played at as an 18/19 year old, most people were playing music on keyboard or guitar. But the performer in the time slot just before me was a magician who got up and started performing magic tricks. He wow’d the small crowd of folks in the bar. Then I got up and had a pretty rough set. Forgot lyrics, broke a string. I had that in my head over the next couple weeks. I was pretty insecure about performing back then, and briefly wondered whether there was any point in doing it when you had guys like this who were performing mind-blowing card magic and I was struggling to put a song together. I quickly caught myself and realised it was silly to compare, but that’s where the magician lyric came from. I suppose now it’s important for me to keep that line at centre of the song because as an artist, you should never compare yourself to anyone else’s creative repertoire or achievements.
Oliver:
You are now able to look back at your 19-year-old self from a different position, having continued to write, perform and release music independently. What do you think that younger version of you would find most surprising about where you are today?
Joseph Mackey:
Not sure if this is the answer you are looking for, but I actually think he would be pretty taken aback with some of the songs I’ve written since then, and their themes; a lot of our current catalogue, and future releases, are vastly different from “Knock”. I was a quite emotionally closed off back then, which made me want to write lyrics in metaphorical language, perhaps to cover things up, rather than an unambiguous tone. Now that I’ve matured a little and opened myself up more, my song-writing style and lyrical inclinations tend to be more vulnerable than they were back in the day.
Oliver:
Coconut Shy began as your solo indie-folk project before evolving into a four-piece band in 2025. What inspired that transition, and how has having other musicians around you changed the way you approach songwriting and performance?
Joseph Mackey:
I had a stack of bedroom-written tunes in my back pocket, and it got to the point where it didn’t feel right being a solo artist anymore. The music needed to be brought to life on stage with a full band; it was yearning for it. As a result the band is now constantly in the back of my mind when I write. Sometimes I’m thinking about the ins and outs of where the bass/electric guitar or drums could go when I am arranging the structure of a song; other times I’ll have no idea how the band could make something work with what I’ve written, but I’m itching to find out. But in any case the evolution from solo artist to band has added a fascinating layer to the songwriting process for me.
Oliver:
You mentioned that your bandmates responded enthusiastically when you introduced “Knock” to them. What did they bring to the song that you could not have achieved through your earlier solo performances?
Joseph Mackey:
I think a couple of them, maybe our bass player Dylan, reassured me that just because it was written so long ago it didn’t necessarily make it not worthy of being a part of our current setlists and discography. Matty’s drums drive the song, particularly the chorus, to a whole new level as well. And the song now feels empty without the other guitars. That’s the way Coconut Shy feels now: I start the songs, and they become finished when all band members contribute their respective parts. “Knock” was of those songs that I could hear what I wanted a band to do with it inside my own head when I was playing on my own, but no one else really could. Until the band.
Oliver:
The track balances introspective songwriting with a punchier indie-rock arrangement. When you and the band began shaping its new version, how did you decide which parts of the original composition needed to remain untouched and which could develop into something bigger?
Joseph Mackey:
The original strumming pattern was a little more choppy, so when Matty was sussing out the drums, it appeared more natural for me to let the chords rings out more, which really informed his drumming style. The bass lines and electric guitar riffs came with natural trial and error as well. We just kept on asking ourselves: what musical elements are going to instinctively complement what the song already is rather than overpower it or try to make something that it isn’t? Its literally creative problem solving.

Oliver:
The recording took place with Simon Paparo at Four Doors Studios. What was the recording experience like, and how did working with Simon help translate the band’s interpretation of the song into the finished release?
Joseph Mackey:
The recording experience at four doors always feels so easy and never feels like work. Simon is great at what he does and has heard enough of our music by now to have knack for finding what we are looking for. It really helps having another person in the room who wasn’t involved in writing the song contribute to the recording of it; he probably acts a source of objectiveness for me, because as the songwriter I obviously have an emotional attachment to the song. Gotta take your hat off to recording engineers; they go through song after song second by second to make sure everything sounds right. Something I would struggle to have the patience for!
Oliver:
Your music draws from a range of influences, including early Coldplay, Dire Straits, Spacey Jane and Mumford & Sons. How do these different musical traditions find their way into Coconut Shy’s sound, and how do you make sure the band’s identity remains its own?
Joseph Mackey:
Honestly, the trick for me is to not think about it too much. I’ve listened to these artists a lot, and many more, so subconsciously I trust that their influence finds its way into our music somehow. But when I’m writing and performing, I’m always conscious of not copying any one style of an artist that has inspired me. It’s important to take an artist’s influence and grow from it in your own authentic way to make sure your band’s identity remains its own. It’s also the ultimate compliment to those artists to do it that way. By copying them, that is a form of compliment as well but in my opinion it’s kind of an insult too.
Oliver:
Before Coconut Shy became a full band, you released an EP in 2021 and later put out “Water, Water” and “The Finest Day”. Those earlier releases also received radio airplay around Australia. How do you view that period of independent work now, and what did it teach you about building a music project without a traditional industry structure behind you?
Joseph Mackey:
I view that period as building block to what Coconut Shy is now. The whole Coconut Shy journey has been a series of small goals that have been reached for. To writing the next song, to getting the next gig, or the next radio interview, or festival slot, whatever it is. I suppose it taught me to simply stick with it, and as long as you’ve got something to say with an authentic and creative voice, it’s worth doing; no matter if you don’t have a traditional industry structure behind you. I also learnt a lot about the value of connecting with other artists who are on a similar journey to myself during that time. Certainly makes things easier (and a lot more fun).
Oliver:
“Knock” follows this year’s singles “Mayfield Blush” and “Small Steps (Paces)”. How do these three releases connect creatively, and do they offer listeners a clearer picture of the direction you are taking with Coconut Shy’s forthcoming debut album?
Joseph Mackey:
Most of them songs were probably written in a similar era, although “Knock” is definitely the oldest song on the album. I hope the singles give a clear enough insight into what the album’s themes are. I tried to couple things like self-doubt, loneliness, acceptance and letting go with inspiration and gratefulness. I think every song on this album can fit into one of those things.
Oliver:
The forthcoming debut album is expected in late 2026. How has the process of preparing your first full-length record as a band differed from releasing individual singles, and what can listeners expect from the wider collection of songs?
Joseph Mackey:
It certainly feels like a there’s a little more at stake with releasing a record! More art, more chances of feeling like you may have made a mistake somewhere but with it more opportunity as a band. It’s exciting. I suppose what’s interesting is that this album is not so much a massive wave of new music from us so much as a collection of releases so far. A lot of the album is already out through singles, save for about 3-4 extra album tracks we are really proud of. I suppose listeners can expect a diverse but hopefully cohesive array of the themes I mentioned in the above question. Songs cut from the same cloth as the singles released this year, but different enough so it makes for an engaging and distinct listener experience. That’s what I hope anyways.
Oliver:
Your songwriting often moves between quiet, personal moments and choruses designed to be sung along to. How important is that balance between intimacy and shared energy when you are writing for Coconut Shy?
Joseph Mackey:
Very important. But in saying that, it’s not really something I actively plan out, it’s just how the songs are written when I’m songwriting in a “flow state” as the psychology world calls it. I’ve always loved songs that take you on a journey through both highs and lows in energetic and personal moments, and also with lyrics. It’s how songs keep you engaged, in my opinion at least. A lot of the music I grew up listening to did just that, so unintentionally it’s probably crept into my songwriting style.
Oliver:
You have described your songs as music for campfire singalongs, coastal drives and quieter afternoons. What kind of emotional connection do you hope listeners develop with your music, and how do you approach writing songs that can fit into such different moments?
Joseph Mackey:
The beauty of music, and art in general, is that consumers can bring their own interpretation and emotional connection to it. That’s all I hope when people listen to the shy. The music itself as you say is very much aligned with certain themes (coastal drives, etc.), but in the case of lyrics, I think in many cases if you set out to spark a specific interpretation or feeling in a listener, a lot of time you may be disappointed. Not all the time, but perhaps more often than not. Everyone is just so different and so many people can have different responses to the same work. I just hope people find an earworm or two in us, and can bring something from their own life to the lyrics which may help them process something better or think about it in a different way. A lot of the time songwriting can be approached based on what mood or mindset the songwriter is in. That sounds obvious to say, but when your mood and mindset changes so too can the songs you create.
Oliver:
With the band continuing to build its catalogue and perform around Melbourne, how has playing live influenced the way you write and arrange songs, particularly now that Coconut Shy has become a four-piece.
Joseph Mackey:
Playing live more you always want to prioritise songs with catchy choruses, the songs we release as singles and the songs that we feel actually say something and display a meaningful message to people. It also feels a lot more natural to play songs faster and louder live. I know I’ve definitely looked back at live recordings of shows and then compared it to studio recordings – there can be quite a difference.
Oliver:
“Knock” began as a song about uncertainty, but its release today seems to carry a more reassuring message about persistence and staying committed to something you believe in. Has making and releasing this song changed the way you think about ambition, success or the idea of having music as a full-time career?
Joseph Mackey:
A little. I’m a lot more confident now I would say. This song is sort of like looking at a journal I wrote a million years ago and now can look back at it with a fresh and wiser mind backed by more life experience and growing sense of maturity that comes with time. The ambition is the same, but the way I feel and think of it is different to back then. The whole experience of releasing it so long after writing it certainly has been liberating as well. It’s nice to give your past self a nod.
Oliver:
As Coconut Shy moves towards its debut album and the next stage of the band’s development, what are you most looking forward to exploring creatively, and are there any musical directions or opportunities you hope to pursue?
Joseph Mackey:
Where do I start? I’m already keen as hell to start releasing the next batch of singles next year honestly. I’m keen to write more, play more. It would be sweet to support some bigger bands next year and perhaps hit a festival stage. We played at a couple of smaller ones this year which was grand so I can only imagine what it’s like to play at bigger ones.

Oliver:
Finally, if someone discovers Coconut Shy for the first time through “Knock”, what would you like them to understand about the band, the person behind the songwriting, and the reason you have continued making music all these years?
Joseph Mackey:
I think I’d want people to understand that Coconut Shy is ultimately a project built around a genuine love of songwriting. It’s been a pretty long journey, and the music has evolved quite a bit along the way, particularly as it’s grown from a solo project into a four-piece band. I just love bringing a song to life; nothing can beat that. As for why I keep making music – it’s just a creative urge and desire that never really leaves (God forbid we are hit with writers block). Also, and this is probably the old Psychology Uni student in me talking, but I love how songwriting involves both halves of your brain. There’s room to be creative and express yourself, but there’s also a sort of unwritten mathematical formula to it too. Some chords work together, some don’t. Some syllables and syntax in language work for a particular strumming pattern, and some don’t. It’s an endless creative problem solving puzzle. Anyways, thanks for having me Oliver!
“Through ‘Knock’, Joseph Mackey turns the uncertainty of his younger songwriting years into a reflection on perseverance, reminding us that sometimes the greatest creative achievement is simply having the courage to keep going.”
~ Oliver (DULAXI Team)
EDITORIAL PERSPECTIVE
What stands out about “Knock” is the relationship between its straightforward songwriting and the fuller identity Coconut Shy has developed as a band. The interplay of its folk foundations and indie-rock arrangement gives Mackey’s personal reflections room to develop without losing their accessibility. The story behind the magician lyric adds another dimension to the composition, revealing how even uncomfortable early experiences can become lasting creative material. Ultimately, the release feels like an important meeting point between personal history and the band’s present direction.
~ Oliver (DULAXI Team)
CLOSING
A special thank you to Joseph Mackey for taking the time to speak with DULAXI and share the experiences, reflections and creative decisions behind Coconut Shy’s latest single, “Knock”. Our conversation offered a closer look at the journey from an uncertain young songwriter to the frontman of a growing four-piece band, as well as the importance of remaining committed to a creative passion even when the destination is not immediately clear.
For listeners discovering Coconut Shy through this interview, “Knock” is a wonderful starting point for exploring the band’s songwriting and musical identity. We also encourage you to revisit “Mayfield Blush” and “Small Steps (Paces)” ahead of the forthcoming debut album. As the band continues to develop its catalogue and pursue new opportunities, it will be interesting to see where this next chapter leads.
Thank you for spending your time with us at DULAXI. This has been Oliver, and we look forward to bringing you more conversations with talented artists and musicians from around the world. Until next time, keep discovering new music and supporting independent creativity.

